Professionalism First
Casting directors are not likely to respond to people who have mirror selfies on their Backstage profile. It is not a good look nor is it professional. It might leave some casting directors wondering as to your seriousness. If you cannot take your headshot seriously, you probably should not expect someone else to.
Even if you really put in an effort to take something decent-looking with your iPhone’s portrait mode, it is easy to tell when you did not go through the trouble of getting professional headshots made, particularly when most actors go through that trouble. Their headshots will be easier to standout in quality comparisons.
To those in casting, this can demonstrate a lack of commitment to the craft. Everyone in the industry will tell you that investing in good actor headshots goes a long way. They are the first impression agents, managers, casting directors, and so on will have of you. So, the effort to get headshots for acting in Los Angeles will be worth it.
Also, from a brand-perspective – because actors are their own brand – your headshots should be consistent. Your portfolio of headshots should have the same feel for quality and vibe across the board. Thus, using a headshot from 10 years ago – with all the technology changes since then – is likely a bad idea, even if it still appears to be your likeness today. The quality difference will likely make it feel different.
Headshots to Represent the Actor
A common reason for immediate dismissal upon seeing a headshot is “they don’t look the part.” This is perfectly okay. After all, you want parts that you can pull off. So, if a casting director gets your headshot and passes it over, it is not necessarily a bad thing. It can be a waste of everyone’s time if your headshot suggests you can pull off a detective and then it turns out in your audition that you can only do bubbly.
If these scenarios are common, it might mean that you and your agent or manager are not on the same page. It is important that you two be coordinated in the roles you want and can do and the roles your agent or manager is submitting your for. So, when your headshot represents you and the roles you can pull off, you increase your chances for getting called in.
In terms of headshots, an innocent young woman most likely looks very different than a bitter ex. A businessman looks very different than a hard biker, and so on. So, you must be ready to cover a range of characters with different headshots and send them out accordingly – assuming you have this range in your look and acting skills. Thus, do not be afraid to get very specific with the looks you want to portray in a headshot. Just be sure you have broad-appeal headshots first. Some casting directors love headshots that have very specific target roles in mind. Others want to see a headshot that exudes an ability for multiple types of roles – that are general but approachable.
Overdoing makeup can be a mistake as it can lead to not being a representation of you. It is true that most sets will have a makeup artist make you up. But you must get invited to that chair first. So, work with a makeup artist that can make you look better without changing your look or over-coloring your face.
Also, be careful to not overdo facial expressions, particularly smiling. When you are in front of the photographer’s camera, try to think in your head about reactionary smiles instead of just “I need to smile, maybe more or maybe less.” Instead, think of a positive experience you recently had or want to have. It could be you greeting your best friend or meeting your idol for the first time. You might also try common scenarios where you are approachable, like greeting the bartender to order a drink, and so on.